Ashes to Ashes
Sorcery
Exile two target nonartifact creatures. Ashes to Ashes deals 5 damage to you.
Drew Tucker
Rulings
If one of the targeted creatures is an illegal target by the time Ashes to Ashes resolves, it still exiles the other one and deals 5 damage to you.
(wotc • 2009-10-01)
If both of the targeted creatures are illegal targets by the time Ashes to Ashes resolves, it’s countered. It doesn’t deal 5 damage to you.
(wotc • 2009-10-01)
Rulings
If one of the targeted creatures is an illegal target by the time Ashes to Ashes resolves, it still exiles the other one and deals 5 damage to you.
(wotc • 2009-10-01)
If both of the targeted creatures are illegal targets by the time Ashes to Ashes resolves, it’s countered. It doesn’t deal 5 damage to you.
(wotc • 2009-10-01)