MTG Modern Update: Impact of Recent Bans & Unbans

Checking in on MTG Modern After the Recent Bans (and Unbans)

Explore the impact of recent card bans and unbans in MTG Modern. Discover the new metagame shifts and standout decks in this evolving format.

We are almost two weeks out from the recent bans in Modern, and there is now enough data to see if anything has really changed. Banning cards like The One Ring and Amped Raptor was an attempt to level the playing field in a format where it seemed as if it was difficult to win if you didn't play those cards. Both cards were two of the most popularly played nonland cards, and it was getting to the point where player sentiment about the format was increasingly poor. Wizards knew that they had to do something, and they also needed to do something that kept things interesting after banning two powerful cards. To keep things fresh, Wizards also unbanned Splinter Twin, Green Sun's Zenith, Mox Opal, and Faithless Looting. This seems to be somewhat reasonable so far. All of the cards light up different archetypes, and this was a clear effort to breathe life into the format. Now that Wizards has made their intentions clear on what they wanted to see out of the format, it begs the question: Has anything actually changed?

Most Popular Cards in the Format Post-Bans

Although it is refreshing to not see The One Ring as the most commonly played card in the format, there are still some of the usual suspects that round out the top ten most played nonland cards. Long story short, the energy decks are still the most popular, and the cards that are staples within the lists unsurprisingly are the most commonly played nonland cards in the format. Oddly enough, it appears that Mardu Energy has now become more popular than Boros Energy, which is an interesting shift.

Since Mardu is more popular now, the second most powerful Lord of the Rings card is now the most popular in Modern. I don't think this card is anywhere near ban-worthy, and I think it is actually a healthy card to have in the format. With the increasing popularity of Mardu and Dimir lists also being relevant in the format, Fatal Push is the second most popular card. It makes sense, as it is just about the most efficient removal that we have available for one mana. (Still waiting for that reprint in Standard, by the way!)

Phlage has received heaps of praise as being one of the most well-designed Magic cards in a long time. It is pretty fair, and it isn't so broken that there are calls for a ban. It is played in all of the energy decks, and also slots into some of the four and five color decks. It is an auto-include mostly if you are playing Red and White in anything. It feels like a format that has fetch lands just begs for players to include this card in their decks. Since Fatal Push with revolt is one of the best ways to remove it, it is likely that we see that card with such a rise in popularity.

Another card that is used for efficient removal is Lightning Bolt. This card makes the top five of most popular nonland cards and for good reason. Decks are combining this with Fatal Push, and some of the cheap exile effects that white offers as well. It makes Mardu the ultimate value combination to deal with the threats in the format. When you also include cards like Galvanic Discharge, it is difficult to play to the board against the energy decks.

Thoughtseize is a staple in all eternal formats. The rise in popularity for Mardu Energy propels it into the fifth most popular card in our list. We are all familiar with it, and it is our least favorite thing to sit across from on turn one, and one of the best things that we can cast on turn one. This continues the theme that Mardu is the most popular deck in the format. What is reassuring, however, is that we no longer see Ocelot Pride and Guide of Souls in the top five like we did before for so long.

A nice motif that we are seeing in the format is that the energy decks, while still the most popular, are becoming less popular overall. There is now more room in the format for other decks to shine. This shift in metagame share suggests that the bans and unbans from Wizards are starting to work as intended. Let's take a look at the overall metashare with the most popular decks among a few archetypes.

Metagame Share Between Decks

We already know that energy takes up the biggest share of the meta. It is a 12% to 9% split between Mardu and Boros, respectively. With these decks still taking up over one-fifth of the meta, it is safe to argue that the energy decks are still an issue, and something else could be banned from it down the line. It isn't nearly as much of a problem as before, if you ask me.

What we love to see is Hollow One having an increase in popularity, as it is now the third-most played aggro deck. This was one that started to get some traction as people began to play The One Ring less and less. The deck takes advantage of the lack of graveyard hate that is played in the format, and stifles the curve of opposing decks by making them discard and draw a bunch of cards. We can expect to see Hollow One remain as one of the better decks as things progress.

On the control side of things, Dimir Murktide is now the most popular deck in that category. Some of the lists aren't even playing Murktide Regent anymore, as Abhorrent Occulus has given so much value. Psychic Frog lights up the deck so much more than older versions, and it synergizes perfectly with everything that was historically played in the list.

Lastly on the control side, it feels like we can't talk about the Modern Format without talking about Tron. Tron is right behind Dimir for the most commonly played control deck, and although the deck will miss The One Ring, it has access to so many powerful spells that it's now just a question of what powerful card will fill that void. Karn giving it access to the toolbox of answers is something that will always be an enticing interaction for players in the format, and it's something that will keep players honest in the format.

The combo decks have the usual culprits, as Broodscale and Breach are two of the most popular. One of the decks that has increased in popularity since the unban is actually the Yawgmoth list. It is listed as "creature toolbox" on a lot of websites that have data for the metagame, but just know that it basically is referring to Yawgmoth Combo. The unbanning of Green Sun's Zenith has added yet another method for this deck to truly be a toolbox, and affords one of the original Modern Archetypes a pleasant rejuvenation.

The format looks healthier for now, so we will have to keep an eye on it. Stay tuned for metagame reviews of the other formats coming soon.

Rate this article

I am a Magic The Gathering competitive player, and streamer. I specialize in homebrew decks. My favorite formats are: Standard, Pioneer (Explorer on Arena), and EDH. I first started playing MTG in 2001, and have played on and off since then.

numb_skull_

Check out more content by Numbskull

Discover why Orzhov Pixie is the top Standard deck in Magic: The Gathering. Explore its consistent mana base and versatile gameplay in our detailed analysis.

Finding the best Pixie Deck in Standard (it's Orzhov)

We just finished up the Regional Championship in Bologna, and we are finally getting some answers in regards to what the best decks are in Standard. We had the confirmation of aggro still being very effective, and those pesky mice continue to do their thing. In addition to that, Izzet Prowess has made a name for itself. Jeskai Control had a good showing, and Domain was still represented as well. We have all known about Esper Pixie for a bit, and many of us have been adequately terrorized by it. A new, more consistent version of this archetype is here and it uses some great cards. This archetype had a good showing at the Regional Championship, and had a list that qualified for the next RC, while just missing a spot at the pro tour. Orzhov Pixie is a deck that aims to be more consistent with its mana, and also allows for a pivot to more of a midrange battle when needed. The plethora of discard and removal make it a deck that is right up my alley, and I will never turn down the opportunity to play cards that make the opponent lose life. Today we are going to examine Orzhov Pixie, and why I believe it is the best version of the Pixie Archetype. We will go over some important cards that this list uses that the Esper version does not, then we will compare the pros and cons of playing each list. This list that was pretty well curated by Massimiliano earned him an honorable finish in Bologna. This player was one win away from a pro tour invitation and at that point, you have to say that they are in the conversation to be considered one of the top-tier players in Europe at least. They will be back for more opportunities to qualify. This deck has started to break into the meta, and it has finally made a name for itself by having three different players finish in the top 64 with the deck. All three players took home at least $500. Not bad for playing your favorite game over a weekend. What strikes me the most in this deck is the versatility of it. There are cards that we can top deck that make it so we are a lot less likely to run out of gas. I think that is what I enjoy most about this compared to the Esper Version. Esper is all in on the combo itself, and it doesn't have as good of a backup plan. This list allows you to play the midrange and attrition-based matchups that are sometimes demanded of you based on what the opponent is playing. The versatility of Orzhov Pixie is what sets it apart. Relevant Cards

This Deck is Sneaky Good! Get Ready for RAKDOS Dragons!

You didn't think I could only give you one dragon deck, did you? I honestly saw too many fun options to do just Boros, so today I'm bringing you another. This one steers toward the more midrange, good ol' honest Magic side of things. I wanted to center a deck around something that is more consistent with the status quo of dragons: carnage and destruction. We have plenty of removal in this deck, and a creature that doubles as a board wipe when needed. Since we aren't doing a super fancy combo in this deck, I wanted to add element of ramp to get to the higher mana spells that we have in the deck. We will be able to use early creatures to help out with that, and also a new fancy artifact. We will torch the board and force our opponents to be more resilient than we are, while flying over the top of what they might manage to keep on the board. Let's take a look at the deck and then I'll tell you some of my favorite things about it. You can see some of the fun that we will have right off the bat with this deck. We are looking to smash aggro decks, and still punish other decks that don't play to the board. Although this one has fewer dragons on paper, we have a few permanents that can actually turn into them, and this leads to some cheeky interactions. Let's check out some of the new cards from Tarkir Dragonstorm that are in this deck, and then we will go over some fun combos! Key New Cards

It's Time to Mobilize the Aristocrats with Mardu Combo!

There is an ongoing argument in both Standard and Pioneer currently. What color combination is the best for aggressive decks? We have seen people try out Jeskai Aggro to try and incorporate the best of both worlds between Azorius Aggro, and Boros Aggro. Some like to stick with Gruul Aggro because of the high rolls that it allows for, and there is also an argument that sometimes all you need is mono red - and the results have proven as much in major events. There has been a bit of a surge of some Mardu Aristocrat/Sacrifice decks, and today's list will follow that to some degree. We went a little bit more aggro-based, but there is a combo element to it, along with a healthy sideboard that should provide for balanced gameplay. We will look to get a bunch of creatures onto the board, and then create a bunch more based on the amount that we have, while punishing the opponent when they die. If that isn't enough, the go-wide strategy should also allow us to swing for ample damage at an ample pace. A new ability called Mobilize that is being brought to us in Tarkir Dragonstorm is going to allow us to pull off some pretty powerful swings in combat. Mobilize allows us to create a bunch of tapped and attacking 1/1 tokens based on either the number behind it, or circumstances that pertain to "X." Something that is particularly fun is that we can benefit from our creatures dying, because the mobilize ability requires us to sacrifice the creatures that we get from mobilizing at the beginning of our end step. This is yet another deck that can allow us to win on the end step which is always fun. Another fundamental reason why I think the deck is good is because we are rewarded for something that would normally be considered a setback. If you find enough ways to turn negatives into positives, it usually can translate into the small margins that win you a match. Enough of me blabbing. Let's take a look at the cool new cards! Key New Cards

Demons Are Getting New Toys, and This Deck is ROTTEN

We have seen the vast majority of the cards that will be released in Tarkir Dragonstorm, and the excitement is definitely building. Magic players are expecting this to meet the hype that Duskmourn brought us, and hopefully more. We were left a bit underwhelmed with Aetherdrift, but this is proving to be all but a filler set. It's something that is so easy to be excited for. Who doesn't love dragons?! Anyone with an ounce of nerdiness is interested as soon as they hear the word. Although I don't have a dragon deck for you today, I am going to do my obligatory Mono Black Deck for the new set. If you have read my articles in the past, you know that I do one every set - and this one is no different. We finally have enough cards from Tarkir to give me what I needed to make a new-and-improved Demons list for you. We have a new one that will let us pull off some combos on earlier turns, and hopefully have a better body early on to put pressure on aggro decks. I think that should give us a better shot against the meta, since the threat of a 5 damage crackback can definitely give someone extra things to consider in combat phases. He also isn't a bad creature to discard, as he has an ability to activate from the graveyard. This will help us against the bounce/pixie decks. We have ample graveyard hate and removal for the graveyard combo decks, so I like most of our matchups against the current meta. The only thing we will have to see with time is if the meta shifts with this monster of a new set. We really have some fun cards to add here, and we are adding another type of threat to the deck. We have historically not used our graveyard for much, but now we are able to get additional value from it with a new addition. Our sideboard even has a dragon with an adventure that reads like The Meathook Massacre! I've said enough, let's check out these cards. Relevant New Cards

Free Dragons = Turn 4 Wins!

We are officially in the perpetual spoiler season of the MTG year, and Wizards has not been disappointing us. Most people can get behind a set centered largely around dragons, and it definitely helps that the plane itself is one that we have wanted to see them bring back for a long time. Over a decade later, we are going back to Tarkir. I played a good bit of Magic and did a lot of deck building the last time we had some fun dragons on Arena, and I knew that this set was going to call me back to those days. My favorite archetype a couple of years ago was Boros Dragons. I largely played that in the Alchemy format, but I am going to bring you a Boros Dragons Standard Deck today. We are going to take advantage of a combo that is used in Standard currently, but we are going to use a different payoff this time. We are going to cast dragons for FREE and then either they will have the opponent dead just from entering, or we will hopefully have a way to give them all haste! We will take a look at the new cards that are awesome. Then I'll let you know about the combo that will help us get there. We want to keep the board as clear as we can for our dragons and then slam them all on the board at once to clean things up. We also have some smaller creatures that we can use to chump block earlier in the game. When needed, we also have board wipes to deal with other creatures. New Cards from Tarkir Dragonstorm

I See a Monument and I want it Painted Black

It's been a few weeks since Aetherdrift came out, and we are starting to see the cards that are standing out in the meta. We didn't expect the set to change things too much with regard to what we have been seeing. What we did get from it is a nice supplement to many other decks. Although we did not get a ton of format-shaping cards, we have seen a couple that have lit up fringe archetypes. What I've brewed for today plays off of a familiar archetype, and it was one that we kind of already had, but it allows us to pivot in a certain way and get additional value from it that we may not have gotten in the past. One of the biggest things that our deck can do is have plenty of action on the end step/cleanup step. It's an interesting scenario because usually when we think of the cleanup step at the end of each turn, we remove damage, and we discard to hand size. Usually discarding to hand size is pretty much the final step, and there aren't any triggers... until now. We will be using Monument to Endurance to have triggers when we discard to hand size, and get additional value from it. Now we don't care if we end the turn with nine or ten cards in hand, because we are going to benefit from it. This will help us possibly get in some finishing damage against our opponent, or get extra value. It is worth noting that this will cause triggered abilities on the cleanup step, and this is something that our opponents can respond to. This has historically been a point in the turn where no player can respond to actions. We'll take a look at the relevant cards in the deck, and then I'll detail a few fun combos that we may see during gameplay. Relevant Cards

Finding the best Pixie Deck in Standard (it's Orzhov)