MTG Modern Update: Impact of Recent Bans & Unbans

Checking in on MTG Modern After the Recent Bans (and Unbans)

Explore the impact of recent card bans and unbans in MTG Modern. Discover the new metagame shifts and standout decks in this evolving format.

We are almost two weeks out from the recent bans in Modern, and there is now enough data to see if anything has really changed. Banning cards like The One Ring and Amped Raptor was an attempt to level the playing field in a format where it seemed as if it was difficult to win if you didn't play those cards. Both cards were two of the most popularly played nonland cards, and it was getting to the point where player sentiment about the format was increasingly poor. Wizards knew that they had to do something, and they also needed to do something that kept things interesting after banning two powerful cards. To keep things fresh, Wizards also unbanned Splinter Twin, Green Sun's Zenith, Mox Opal, and Faithless Looting. This seems to be somewhat reasonable so far. All of the cards light up different archetypes, and this was a clear effort to breathe life into the format. Now that Wizards has made their intentions clear on what they wanted to see out of the format, it begs the question: Has anything actually changed?

Most Popular Cards in the Format Post-Bans

Although it is refreshing to not see The One Ring as the most commonly played card in the format, there are still some of the usual suspects that round out the top ten most played nonland cards. Long story short, the energy decks are still the most popular, and the cards that are staples within the lists unsurprisingly are the most commonly played nonland cards in the format. Oddly enough, it appears that Mardu Energy has now become more popular than Boros Energy, which is an interesting shift.

Magic the Gathering Card - Orcish Bowmasters - MTG Circle

Since Mardu is more popular now, the second most powerful Lord of the Rings card is now the most popular in Modern. I don't think this card is anywhere near ban-worthy, and I think it is actually a healthy card to have in the format. With the increasing popularity of Mardu and Dimir lists also being relevant in the format, Fatal Push is the second most popular card. It makes sense, as it is just about the most efficient removal that we have available for one mana. (Still waiting for that reprint in Standard, by the way!)

Magic the Gathering Card - Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury - MTG Circle

Phlage has received heaps of praise as being one of the most well-designed Magic cards in a long time. It is pretty fair, and it isn't so broken that there are calls for a ban. It is played in all of the energy decks, and also slots into some of the four and five color decks. It is an auto-include mostly if you are playing Red and White in anything. It feels like a format that has fetch lands just begs for players to include this card in their decks. Since Fatal Push with revolt is one of the best ways to remove it, it is likely that we see that card with such a rise in popularity.

Another card that is used for efficient removal is Lightning Bolt. This card makes the top five of most popular nonland cards and for good reason. Decks are combining this with Fatal Push, and some of the cheap exile effects that white offers as well. It makes Mardu the ultimate value combination to deal with the threats in the format. When you also include cards like Galvanic Discharge, it is difficult to play to the board against the energy decks.

Magic the Gathering Card - Thoughtseize - MTG Circle

Thoughtseize is a staple in all eternal formats. The rise in popularity for Mardu Energy propels it into the fifth most popular card in our list. We are all familiar with it, and it is our least favorite thing to sit across from on turn one, and one of the best things that we can cast on turn one. This continues the theme that Mardu is the most popular deck in the format. What is reassuring, however, is that we no longer see Ocelot Pride and Guide of Souls in the top five like we did before for so long.

A nice motif that we are seeing in the format is that the energy decks, while still the most popular, are becoming less popular overall. There is now more room in the format for other decks to shine. This shift in metagame share suggests that the bans and unbans from Wizards are starting to work as intended. Let's take a look at the overall metashare with the most popular decks among a few archetypes.

Metagame Share Between Decks

We already know that energy takes up the biggest share of the meta. It is a 12% to 9% split between Mardu and Boros, respectively. With these decks still taking up over one-fifth of the meta, it is safe to argue that the energy decks are still an issue, and something else could be banned from it down the line. It isn't nearly as much of a problem as before, if you ask me.

What we love to see is Hollow One having an increase in popularity, as it is now the third-most played aggro deck. This was one that started to get some traction as people began to play The One Ring less and less. The deck takes advantage of the lack of graveyard hate that is played in the format, and stifles the curve of opposing decks by making them discard and draw a bunch of cards. We can expect to see Hollow One remain as one of the better decks as things progress.

On the control side of things, Dimir Murktide is now the most popular deck in that category. Some of the lists aren't even playing Murktide Regent anymore, as Abhorrent Occulus has given so much value. Psychic Frog lights up the deck so much more than older versions, and it synergizes perfectly with everything that was historically played in the list.

Lastly on the control side, it feels like we can't talk about the Modern Format without talking about Tron. Tron is right behind Dimir for the most commonly played control deck, and although the deck will miss The One Ring, it has access to so many powerful spells that it's now just a question of what powerful card will fill that void. Karn giving it access to the toolbox of answers is something that will always be an enticing interaction for players in the format, and it's something that will keep players honest in the format.

The combo decks have the usual culprits, as Broodscale and Breach are two of the most popular. One of the decks that has increased in popularity since the unban is actually the Yawgmoth list. It is listed as "creature toolbox" on a lot of websites that have data for the metagame, but just know that it basically is referring to Yawgmoth Combo. The unbanning of Green Sun's Zenith has added yet another method for this deck to truly be a toolbox, and affords one of the original Modern Archetypes a pleasant rejuvenation.

The format looks healthier for now, so we will have to keep an eye on it. Stay tuned for metagame reviews of the other formats coming soon.

Rate this article

I am a Magic The Gathering competitive player, and streamer. I specialize in homebrew decks. My favorite formats are: Standard, Pioneer (Explorer on Arena), and EDH. I first started playing MTG in 2001, and have played on and off since then.

numb_skull_

Check out more content by Numbskull

Discover why the Rakdos Demons deck is dominating the Pioneer metagame! Explore strategies, key cards, and how to counter this powerful midrange deck.

This Deck is Giving Everyone PROBLEMS in Pioneer

This is starting to feel like déjà vu. Remember the last time a Rakdos Deck was extremely powerful and the most popular deck in Pioneer? Interestingly enough, it is another midrange shell with a powerful combo. What's different this time, however, is that the cards are a lot more fair. This list is a little bit more well-balanced in my opinion. There is no broken turn three "deal with a Veinripper or lose" in this deck. It simply uses all of the best midrange value cards so well and with such synergy that most decks in the format cannot keep up. Nothing in the deck really feels broken to the point where you could pick out what card to ban. A lot of the cards that are good in the deck are played in other decks, so bans could have adverse effects that aren't good for the format. Nonetheless, the meta will either have to adapt to it, or we will need to see some new cards printed that make another deck good, or there will possibly end up being a ban. Rakdos Demons currently takes up 46% of the metashare, and it has plenty of top finishes in every tournament that it's in. To put things in perspective, the next closest deck in the format when it comes to metashare popularity is a few decks that have 6%. Rakdos Demons has consumed the format, and it would be hard to find someone who would tell you that it isn't the best deck. What's nice about it is that it is also playable on Arena, and because of Pioneer Masters, we aren't even missing any cards. You can jam this on MTGO, or Arena, or in paper. Either way you spin it, this deck kills! What I find interesting about how this deck has developed is that the list only plays two actual demon spells now. We have moved past the other demons that were in the list that could make things a bit clunky. Now, the deck is much faster. It has a lot of plays on turns two and three, and plays threats on those turns that demand answers, as opposed to dropping bombs on turn four. This deck oddly enough, only has 2 four mana spells. It's astonishing how much the list has evolved, and also how aggressive it has become with the tweaks. You've likely seen a few of these lists floating around, as it has been a deck for a few months now, so I will go over a couple of cards that have been added to it recently that contribute to the aggressive nature of the deck. New Additions

It's Official, We've Lived Long Enough to See Ourselves Become the Villain. Time for Mono Black Discard

There comes a time in every Magic player's tenure where they are simply fed up with everything that they are seeing in the meta. Some move to playing decks that remove everything, or decks that counter everything - sometimes both. Some of us simply don't let our opponents have any cards in hand, and that's what I've opted to do today. There's something that just feels right about making the opponent have zero cards in their hand while we continue to draw and play threats onto the board. Discard went well in the meta a few months ago before Duskmourn came out, and I think it is possible for it to be good again. The win rate so far with our deck is solid, but it is different from the one we played before. This time we are looking to add some card superiority into the list, and the same card that accomplishes that allows us to play fewer creatures to focus on more discard spells, and efficient removal. Let's take a look at the new discard deck in the Foundations Meta. This deck got a little bit more consistency and some extra win conditions from Duskmourn, and it is refreshing to know that we have more threats to draw, and we now have a higher likelihood of drawing them. We want to try and draw as many cards as we can with this deck, because some of the better lists that are out there will also draw a ton of cards. We look to punish our opponent for drawing cards, and for not having cards in their hand. We also look to benefit from drawing cards while punishing our opponent simultaneously. The list has a ton of removal, because frankly there are some cards that are just too difficult to deal with in Standard and I got sick of waiting to sideboard and hoping that I drew the answers. We will go over the key changes from previous versions, and then we will go over the sideboard guide! New Additions to Mono Black Discard

A Product Change is Coming to Play Booster Boxes, and People are NOT Happy

Although we are still getting used to the new cards brought to us by Foundations, we have begun to get announcements about the next Standard-legal set, Aetherdrift. Aetherdrift will be the first set to come out in 2025, and it will also be the first Universes Beyond Standard-legal set. For those who aren't familiar, Universes Beyond sets are the ones that do not exclusively involve the traditional MTG characters and planes, although they can still be incorporated. What they do for the characters in the Universes Beyond sets is to have somewhat of a crossover between MTG and another universe in popular culture. We have seen them do Lord of the Rings, Assassin's Creed, etc. What is unique about the Universes Beyond sets going forward is that they will now be Standard-legal - something that has not been the case up until now. In fact, almost all of the Universes Beyond sets were strictly Commander, Legacy, and Vintage-legal up until now, with the exception of Lord of the Rings also being legal in Modern. That is a change that we did know about , however, but the latest updates follow up on the new changes that we will see starting next year. Changes to Play Booster Boxes So what is this big change? How will it affect MTG?

The Overlords Have Spoken! GRUUL is Surprisingly Fun!

It's no secret that in Standard we have some absolutely monstrous creatures right now. There are multiple ways to cheat them out, and the most immediate one that comes to mind is reanimator. With Foundations, we also get a bit more access to ramp, and the overlords from Duskmourn have been pretty impactful in the format as well. So the idea is that we can center a deck around having a bunch of enter-the-battlefield effects or attack triggers that allow us to commit some serious shenanigans. In Gruul Surprise, we are going to cheat out the big guys as best we can, be it ramp, or with a card that says we can simply put them on the board. Since we can sometimes do this at instant speed, it insulates us against board wipes, and allows us to set up one-turn kills. The idea is that we can get around control decks and punish opponents who didn't leave up any blockers. We are also looking to ping our opponents for tons of damage just by having creatures enter under our control. Since we are playing 7 overlords, we are also going to play Up the Beanstalk because it will allow us to draw a bunch of extra cards. OK, I have hyped up this fun deck enough. Let's take a look at the list! The addition of Llanowar Elves has really helped this deck to be more consistent and possibly try to keep up with the fast meta. We have access to the smaller board wipes that deal with aggro decks, while not killing all of our stuff. The deck does a great job of going over the top and running away with the game if left unchecked. Most of the time, playing against it feels like a ticking time bomb. We are able to deal pretty significant damage that forces the opponent to be very selective with when they attack, and when they leave up mana for removal. Let's take a look at some key cards. Relevant Cards

Reviewing the Standard Metagame and the Domination of Aggro

We are a couple of weeks into Foundations, and it feels like the meta is starting to respond. There were some good staple creatures added to the format, and we even got back some nostalgic burn spells. Midrange is still pretty good, but the decks are forced more and more into a sideboard plan that is almost entirely geared toward dealing with aggro. If you hadn't noticed how prevalent aggro has become recently, it now accounts for 74% of the decks that are listed in major tournaments in Standard. The most recent MTGO Challenge actually featured an entire top 8 consisting of assorted aggro decks. One could make the argument that some of the decks were more tempo than aggro, but the decks have aggressive creatures nonetheless, and they also all tend to have a low curve. We could also conclude that the addition of Llanowar Elves makes the Golgari decks that much faster, and then in some instances they could have been considered an aggro deck. Mono red is also taking up more and more of the competitive metashare, and is positioning itself as a deck to be reckoned with ever since its strong showing at the World Championships. We will look over some of the archetypes in Standard right now that are consistently performing well in challenges and other tournaments. Red Deck Wins This has remained a relevant deck for over a year now, and has endured many changes. It seems that the deck can always find a worthy replacement once a card either rotates or becomes subpar. There are a few new burn spells in Foundations, so it has become evident that burn could be here to stay for the next few years. It's going to be strong most likely for as long as Bloomburrow is in Standard. I think this is good for the game, and lines up with what Wizards wants. You want people to get into your game and garner new players with Foundations, so why not make sure mono red is good? It is one of the preconstructed decks on Arena, and it is one of the easier archetypes for a new player to learn. It lines up with everything that they want, and also allows for newer players to have a positive experience with a good deck that can win games early on in their journey. It is also pretty helpful that a lot of the cards are on the cheaper end. Just make sure you save up for your sideboard - Screaming Nemesis is steadily climbing and could get to fifty bucks soon!

The BEST New Deck to Play with Pioneer Masters!

Pioneer Masters is coming in December, and we officially have some spoilers. We won't go over all of the new that were announced recently, as there aren't quite enough to devote an entire article to yet, but we have some good news that confirms the inclusion of key decks and archetypes into the explorer format that will eventually convert to Pioneer on Arena. Something that we have to consider is that Explorer on Arena is far from actually being Pioneer. There are a ton of cards that are missing, and in turn, there are very powerful decks from the format that we have never seen on Arena before. If you don't play Pioneer in paper, or in MTGO, you may not have ever heard of some of the stuff that's coming. I have some advice: prepare yourself. There will be a brand new meta after Pioneer Masters hits Arena, and Explorer will look nothing like it did before. Today I have a deck that I believe to have an incredibly high power level, and also one of the decks that I believe to be the most consistent in the format. It has the best removal possible, has a spell that tutors and allows you to cast the spells for free, access to five colors, and some powerful creatures and planeswalkers that allow you to close out the game. Let's take a look at Niv to Light. Niv to Light is a deck that has been played for a few years in Pioneer, and it seems to get updates here and there. There are some new cards from Foundations that are seeing play in the deck, and I'm not sure if that is the final version of it, or if people are simply trying out some of these new cards. What I will say is that the deck has been doing very well in some of the recent Pioneer challenges on MTGO, with this list winning one just a few days ago on the 23rd. If you aren't familiar, there is a key combo in the deck that actually allows you to tutor out a seven mana planeswalker and cast it for free, amongst a plethora of other value spells. We'll take a look at that particular combo, and then other key cards of the deck. Relevant Combo Cards

This Deck is Giving Everyone PROBLEMS in Pioneer