What Makes a Good Build-Around Card?

Updated:
Discover what makes a card a pivotal build-around in Magic: The Gathering. This guide breaks down the essentials for creating powerful decks.

Why Seek Good Build Arounds?

Magic: the Gathering is many things to many people, so for some readers, this topic might not be relevant at all, but if you clicked on the headline, I'm guessing you can appreciate building a deck from scratch. The experience of building a brand-new Magic deck and the experience of playing a deck tightly are completely different, but both have their place.

Ultimately, Magic: the Gathering is a game and you need to make sure you're engaging with the elements of it that you find most rewarding emotionally. If you aren't having fun (in one way or another), I would highly recommend you change something. Personally, I find fun in turning underappreciated cards into functional decks that are able to win even when they're up against proven strategies. Even if my win rate would be higher with an established deck, I would rather spend my time engaging with my own creations and try to bring out the best in them.

The End Goal

Before you start to build any deck, make sure you have a clear understanding of your objective. Is the goal to climb to Mythic on Arena, or is the goal to simply see if a dud rare you opened can be viable in the current meta? There are a number of build-around cards where you need to start by exploring the possibilities.

Be honest with yourself and if a build-around doesn't look competitive, know that it probably isn't, and that's okay. Reframe your goal from 'get to mythic with X,' to 'see how consistent I can make X.' Also know that playing on Arena means you'll go up against top-tier meta decks even in the play queue given how the system heavily incentivizes wins.

The Criteria

There are a few criteria I use whenever I'm judging a build-around card. They come down to:

  1. What is this card asking of me?
  2. What is the payoff for performing that action?
  3. Can this payoff win me a game?
  4. Can I pull this off in the current meta?

When we look at cards that see play in competitive formats, they often ask very little in the way of setup while providing value that is beyond what you'd get for that kind of mana with other available options. To illustrate my point, I'm going to break down how a few meta cards fit this bill.

Raffine, Scheming Seer is incredible and the defining build-around linchpin of the Esper Midrange list that made up a huge percentage of the field at the last pro tour. The card asks only that you have at least one other creature on board that can attack, and the payoff is excellent card selection and a stat boost to the attacking creature. The fact that Raffine herself also has flying is gravy that allows her to get the job done even if you don't manage to have another creature on board earlier. The investment is negligible and the payoff outstrips most other three-mana options you'll find in the format.

Atraxa is an interesting case because she costs seven mana, which is a lot, and it requires four separate colors. In order for her to work, you need to ramp aggressively, which isn't always easy to pull off, so the ask here is actually very high. But, in return for pulling this off, you get to put 3-6 cards into your hand with selection and place a body on board that can stabilize from almost any losing board state. If she or you aren't eliminated immediately, she'll probably win you the game. This is how good seven drops have to be in order to see meaningful play.

Atraxa also presents the best option at seven mana by a mile, which can be problematic if you want to ramp into anything else or reanimate anything else. You have to ask yourself, 'would this strategy be better if the payoff was just Atraxa,' and, unfortunately for us jank lovers, the answer is usually yes.

As I'm looking at these, I'm realizing most of the big threats in Standard are female presenting and I think that's just neat. Representation for the win. Anyway, Sheoldred is an interesting case because she asks the player to get to four mana. That's not difficult at all, and the payoff that you get is an overstated monster that will simply win the game by sitting on the board. This card is arguably fair because it's a creature that's susceptible to removal, but if the opponent doesn't have removal on-hand, she practically wins the game on the spot. Definitely worth the price.

Commander vs. Standard

In Commander, you can build nearly anything at all because the social contract places arbitrary rules on the game to help encourage enjoyment from every player. I enjoy Commander and I think it has its place as an alternative to a boardgame played with friends, but taking that mentality into a 60-card constructed format like Standard will often get you, as a deck builder, into trouble.

The reason I decided to write this article today is because I've been trying to build a deck in Standard taking advantage of Jaxis, the Troublemaker and Ertha Jo, Frontier Mentor. This combo allows the creation of multiple tokens in a single activation, extra card draw, and gigantic boards if Ratadrabik of Urborg is around. Every attempt at the deck failed and I found it very frustrating. My goal had been to create a competitive deck around this combo, but that goal wasn't realistic given the tools I was working with. Let's break down the pieces.

Ertha Jo is an interesting card that asks you to target creatures or players with abilities that would be good in multiples. There's the obvious mercenary synergy, but this also works with planeswalker abilities that target players such as Liliana of the Veil. The effect is powerful, but it asks you to stick a four-drop creature, keep it around, and then also have another permanent with a specific type of activated ability on board. The ask is steep enough to be challenging in Standard, and the payoff is not good enough to win a game.

Jaxis is a fun card that has a Kiki-Jiki style ability that can be situationally powerful, but this incarnation of it has a lot of safety valves that make it suboptimal. Having to discard a card is a huge cost, and if the token is exiled, you never replace it in your hand. We also have a ton of board wipes in Standard that means we aren't likely to see another turn if the copied permanent doesn't win the game on the spot. The current meta is just very hostile to creatures, so having a factory that can create a lot of them just isn't good enough to carry the day anymore.

So, is My Pet Card a Good Build Around?

You can approach building around a card or combo in a number of ways. If your goal is to simply see if it's viable and you will take pleasure in the journey, then have had it and have some fun. Wrack up those losses but learn lessons and smile along the way. If, like me, you find losing disheartening and want to focus in on decks that can win in the current meta, consider the criteria I mentioned and try to find cards that offer a minimal cost and a payoff that can win the game. Any card can bring you joy if you're receptive to the kind of experience it can give you. Just be realistic in your expectations and have fun.

Also, if you find yourself frustrated that you aren't getting the results you're after, don't hesitate to scrap a deck. Accepting that an idea doesn't work just frees you up to move on to the next idea, or revisit a deck you know works that makes you happy. Never forget that this is a game. Games are fun. Let's keep it fun.

Happy brewing!

Rate this article
Graham, also known as HamHocks42 on the internet, is a Twitch streamer who adores Magic: the Gathering in all its forms and tries to find the fun, even in the most competitive and sweaty environments.

Check out more content by HamHocks42

Explore the rise of Brawl in MTG Arena's Historic format. Discover popular commanders, deck-building tips, and why it's perfect for casual Magic players.
Is Brawl the Next Big Thing?
Today, Wizards put out an article detailing the current state of MTG Arena formats and play rates across them. They did a similar post last year and there were many details that weren't exactly surprising. Standard remains the most popular format by a wide margin with Best-of-1 being preferred over Best-of-3 by a large number of players. Timeless is the newest addition to the list and, as one might expect, has the lowest adoption rate of the official formats. One detail stood out, however, as a significant change over last year's data, and that is the play rate associated with Brawl. What is Brawl? If you’re not familiar, Brawl is a format that is similar to Commander, but it includes only the cards available on Arena. You select a commander to helm your deck which can be any legendary creature or (unlike the Commander format) a planeswalker. You have access to your commander at all times as a sort-of eighth card in your hand and if it is killed or exiled, you can return it to its starting location, the “command zone,” and recast it with an additional two mana “commander tax” added to its casting cost.
Discover the latest Magic: The Gathering releases, including upcoming sets like Aetherdrift and Universes Beyond, and their impact on Standard format.
Magic’s Upcoming Releases
At MagicCon Vegas over the past weekend, Wizards of the Coast unveiled a number of new products they’ll be releasing over the next year to a variety of fan reactions. Many of these sets and supplemental items will be paper-exclusive, but a fair number of them will be coming to Arena, so I wanted to break them down and discuss what we can expect from these sets. Magic Foundations
Discover the joy of playing huge spells in Magic: The Gathering Standard! Dive into this casual deck tech with powerful cards and creative strategies.
Playing HUGE Spells in Standard
Today's deck is nothing short of a disaster, but a beautiful disaster that has brought me a lot more joy than other decks I've been playing recently. The deck is all-in on doing gigantic silly things with exorbitant mana costs that would generally be more unattainable than a poorly named plot contrivance in Avatar; but we can get there due to a deceptively powerful Leyline that, as of this writing, is still legal in Best-of-One… and will continue to be because I'm talking about Leyline of Mutation. The Cornerstone Leyline of Mutation, like any Leyline, can start the game on the battlefield if it's in your opening hand but it would cost four otherwise. Generally, this mana disparity means they're useless if they aren't in your opening hand because the effect can't be game-breaking if it's on the battlefield at the start of the game, but four mana is a significant cost.
Explore how Duskmourn cards enhance the Insidious Roots combo deck for Magic: The Gathering. Discover new strategies for powerful, surprising wins.
Duskmourn Supercharges Insidious Roots
Insidious Roots is a combo deck that's near and dear to my heart, and a number of Dusourn cards slot into it in powerful and interesting ways that allow us to upgrade the build to possibly generate more consistent gameplay. The Core Combo If you didn't read my last article talking about the previous version of Insidious Roots combo, here's a quick rundown. This is a combo deck designed to get a one-hit kill that the opponent will likely not see coming after comboing off with the following three cards.
Explore the power of Doomsday Excruciator in Standard Magic: The Gathering. Discover how to build competitive and casual mill decks in our latest deck tech.
Standard Doomsday Mill
Mill is an often misunderstood and maligned archetype that gets people hot and bothered in multiple ways. As a reanimator player, I love watching my deck flip into my graveyard, but for the rest of the player base, it’s often a frustrating sensation as a world of possibilities unravels before their eyes. Well, there are a ton of cards from Duskmourn that support a mill package, and I want to focus on one today: Doomsday Excruciator. Doomsday Excruciator is a throwback reference to the card Doomsday, which strips your library down to only five cards that you hand select. The potential of this card is bananas and is the backbone of combo decks in Vintage and Legacy. Unfortunately, Doomsday Excruciator is nowhere near as good with twice the mana investment, and it doesn't allow you to select the cards you're left with, which means it just doesn't do the same thing. What the Build Around Does Well
Master the current Magic: The Gathering Standard meta with strategic deck-building tips. Counter top archetypes and enhance your brew's success rate.
Tips for Taking on the Current Standard Meta
Brewing decks is more than just finding a card that inspires you and picking what cards to put around it. You also have to take into account the context the deck finds itself in. If your brew is soft to the most popular deck in the format, it’s just not going to be successful no matter how consistent it is when put against different matchups. Power creep exacerbates this as the speed of the game increases, requiring your deck to either pop off faster or answer a variety of threats within even the first two turns in order to be successful. Today, I want to look at the most popular archetypes in Standard and look at play patterns we can focus on to give our janky brews a fighting chance. Red-Based Aggro
Explore the rise of Brawl in MTG Arena's Historic format. Discover popular commanders, deck-building tips, and why it's perfect for casual Magic players.
Is Brawl the Next Big Thing?
Today, Wizards put out an article detailing the current state of MTG Arena formats and play rates across them. They did a similar post last year and there were many details that weren't exactly surprising. Standard remains the most popular format by a wide margin with Best-of-1 being preferred over Best-of-3 by a large number of players. Timeless is the newest addition to the list and, as one might expect, has the lowest adoption rate of the official formats. One detail stood out, however, as a significant change over last year's data, and that is the play rate associated with Brawl. What is Brawl? If you’re not familiar, Brawl is a format that is similar to Commander, but it includes only the cards available on Arena. You select a commander to helm your deck which can be any legendary creature or (unlike the Commander format) a planeswalker. You have access to your commander at all times as a sort-of eighth card in your hand and if it is killed or exiled, you can return it to its starting location, the “command zone,” and recast it with an additional two mana “commander tax” added to its casting cost.
logo

By joining our community, you can immerse yourself in MTG Arena gameplay. Watch matches, engage with content, comment, share thoughts, and rate videos for an interactive experience.

Follow Us

LATEST VIDEOS