What Makes a Healthy Standard?

Updated:
Explore the dynamics of a healthy Standard in Magic: The Gathering. Learn how player choices and card balance shape a vibrant, competitive metagame.

You've probably heard loudmouth streamers (like myself) espousing that Standard is healthy and in a good place right now. But what does that mean? Those exact same streamers will load up the ladder and immediately complain about specific cards they see (yep, still me). Is the format being healthy not synonymous with the players enjoying themselves? Surely that doesn't make any sense.

So how can these two contradictions exist so passionately, sometimes even within one individual?

Defining Healthy

For any game to be healthy, you need one thing: players. Triple-A video game executives don’t care about whether or not their communities are toxic or even having fun so long as they keep showing up and spending money. Magic: the Gathering isn’t really any different when you think about it. At the end of the day, as long as we keep showing up to play a given format, the format should be considered healthy.

That said, the Magic player base is a pretty discerning lot and we are spoiled for choice. If a format like Standard or Modern is not particularly fun, we can put it down without giving up Magic entirely. We can simply switch constructed formats, get into Commander, or play our favorite limited formats.

We see Standard players taking advantage of this a lot because of Standard's rotating nature. Every few months the format shifts dramatically, so the players who enjoy it one month might dislike it after a set or two are released. We all know we can put it down for a year and come back to something completely different later. Of course, there's always a chance those players won't come back later.

How to Combat Unhealthy Standards

Currently, there is really only one tool in Wizards of the Coast's tool belt for fixing a broken MTG format: banning cards. The reason for this is pretty simple. In paper, the cards are printed with rules text permanently on the physical game piece. If a card is functionally changed so it legally behaves differently than what’s printed, there’s a chance a player seeing it for the first time will be confused.

Of course, there are exceptions to this in extreme cases. Companions, for example, were errata'd to add a 3-mana tax to put them to hand. This was a pretty extreme case because companions were appearing in the majority of decks at the time and created a homogenous experience that turned players off in droves. This shouldn’t be looked at as a precedent, but rather an emergency course correction from a mechanic that risked alienating an entire generation of early Arena adopters.

While bans can help minimize the damage problematic cards create, it should be seen as a last resort. In the past few years, we've needed a number of bans in Standard as some design choices proved too aggressive for a healthy format. Fortunately, the recent sets don't seem to follow this trend and it's my sincere hope that this continues and Standard bans can become a thing of the past again soon.

But What Makes a Problematic Card?

In order to ban problematic cards, you need to be able to identify them. When you play for a while, you get a sense of what play patterns are generally fun and which are frustrating, but since taste is subjective, just trusting a person’s gut isn’t sufficient. We need to look at concrete data. Fortunately, MTGA and MTGO are treasure troves of data regarding play rates and win rates, but the other key data that we can leverage is tournament results. We should review tournament results and hold them in higher regard than anecdotal ladder experiences because they represent the format at its most fundamental level.

If there is a way to combat a popular strategy, tournament grinders gunning for prizes will find it. Then, once the word gets out, that strategy will become more popular and the previously powerful, problematic, strategy will become naturally less problematic. This is a healthy metagame – one where the players have a say over which cards can be played because multiple powerful cards naturally check each other.

Problems arise in cases like Oko, Thief of Crowns, or Omnath, Locus of Creation when they are significantly stronger than the alternatives and lack reasonable counter play. That's when the ban hammer comes down.

Powerful vs. Too Powerful

Current Standard has many cards in it that negate other strategies or represent powerful swings that can be difficult to deal with. The two I've highlighted above, Sheoldred, the Apocalypse, and Sunfall are cards currently legal in Standard that see some play, but their meta share has fallen dramatically in the past few months with more aggressive strategies just outperforming them.

These are cards people have called out as candidates for banning in the past. No action was taken against them and over time, their usage simply dropped off. Players learned to adapt and challenge them and they're no longer defining parts of the Standard landscape but simply another option within it. These cards, regardless of your personal feelings towards them, represent what healthy inclusions in Standard look like.

So Why Are Tensions Still High Sometimes?

The bottom line is that some players will never be satisfied and we need to accept that somewhere, someone will complain about anything. For example, my least favorite card in Standard is Deep-Cavern Bat, but I'll be the first to tell you it isn't a problematic card. If we break down why it bothers me, it's because it shines a light on glaring holes within my own game.

I play decks that rely on individual cards to be effective (often all-in combos), I usually don't have enough threats to put my opponent in uncomfortable blocking positions, and I rarely run enough removal. Deep-Cavern Bat isn't a problematic card – I personally have bad habits the bat punishes.

If you find yourself saying, “Man, they really ought to ban _____,” try to think through what types of decks aren't affected by that card and compare them to the decks you're running. There's likely a disconnect there, but there are often lessons to be learned that you can apply to your own play and card choices. Sometimes there's a problem in the format, but there's often a solution you can employ that doesn't require Wizards taking action.

A healthy Standard is one where you have the power to combat the popular strategies. So go out there and make it happen!

Thank you for reading, and happy brewing!

Rate this article
Graham, also known as HamHocks42 on the internet, is a Twitch streamer who adores Magic: the Gathering in all its forms and tries to find the fun, even in the most competitive and sweaty environments.

Check out more content by HamHocks42

Explore the top cards from Tarkir: Dragonstorm for Magic: The Gathering Standard. Discover new strategies and meta shifts in this competitive spoiler analysis.
Tarkir: Dragonstorm Cards for Standard So Far
Tarkir: Dragonstorm will be launching on Magic: the Gathering Arena on Tuesday, April 8th, so until we get our hands on the products, jank lovers like myself and, possibly, yourself are stuck speculating on which cards will be good enough to cut it in Standard. So far, with only a few days of preview season under our belts, a few have caught my attention as powerful enough to possibly make the cut. A lot of the current meta, think of as Gruul Mice and Esper Pixie, are very tuned decks and I don't expect these to get many new toys that will be faster or more consistent than their current pieces. That said, I believe (or vainly hope) that a few new archetypes will get the support they need to step up and challenge the current meta in a fun way. Let's look at what those are. Midrange
Explore the unique Aetherspark in Magic: The Gathering's Historic Brawl. Discover its synergy with colorless creatures, ramp strategies, and Eldrazi payoffs.
Brawl Break: The Aetherspark
The Aetherspark is one of the goofiest types lines on any Magic: the Gathering card we've ever seen before. A Legendary Artifact Planeswalker – Equipment is certainly a novel string of words , and because the word “planeswalker” is in there, the card is eligible to be a Brawl commander. So, of course, I built it. How to Even Begin?
Explore the Radiant Lotus Combo in Standard Magic: The Gathering. Discover artifact synergies, mana generation, and strategic plays for Best of 1 matches.
Radiant Lotus Combo in Standard
The best cards in Standard are making it difficult to brew these days, but where there's a will, there's a way. The current meta is dominated by "This Town Ain't Big Enough" and "Up the Beanstalk" piles, but other cards like Simulacrum Synthesizer and The Mightstone and Weakstone are powerhouse value engines in their own right if we can find a shell for them that works. We also have an absolute haymaker in Radiant Lotus that I'm finally willing to brew with and, I've got to say, I'm impressed. The Wincon
Discover our first impressions of Tarkir: Dragonstorm with highlights on new cards - Mox Jasper & Stormscale Scion. Explore the impacts on MTG Standard play
Our First Impressions of Tarkir: Dragonstorm
Last week, Wizards of the Coast gave us a first look at the next Standard release, Tarkir: Dragonstorm, and that gives us an opportunity to analyze, overreact, and wildly speculate on what the future holds, which is an opportunity I rarely pass up. This first look was only nine cards from the Standard set itself, but it includes some eye-catching mechanics, so let's get into it. For this article, I plan to analyze how these cards will impact Standard first and foremost. The Headliner
Explore a unique Abzan Reanimator deck in MTG Standard featuring Atraxa, Grand Unifier, and Zombify. Unleash powerful reanimation with strategic twists.
Abzan Reani-Midrange
The quest for a quality reanimator deck is never-ending for graveyard junkies like myself, and a Standard that includes Atraxa, Grand Unifier and Zombify is just begging for it. So today, I have a fresh take on the archetype in Abzan with a bit of a twist. The Main Threats
Explore the Speedbrood's transformation into vehicles in our Magic: The Gathering Standard BO1 deck. Discover top strategies for competitive play.
Insects in Standard Best-of-One
One of the racing teams competing for the Aetherspark in Aetherdrift is the Speedbrood, a species of insects that have such a strong connection with speed itself that they literally transform into vehicles upon achieving their version of enlightenment. Well, that means they're well represented as a draft archetype in DFT and we're able to take advantage of it and ultimately build a pretty slick Standard deck that can hang in best-of-one (BO1) pretty well, even if it would likely falter in games two and three if we tried it in BO3. The Win Conditions Our primary finisher is Aatchik, Emerald Radian, which gives us a gigantic board state just for entering the battlefield, and each insect we have suddenly pings our opponent upon death. This makes blocking them a challenge and almost guarantees they'll give you the chance to push damage. Obviously, for us to get Aatchik's enters-the-battlefield (ETB) trigger to maximum value, we'll need to run lots of artifacts and creatures in our deck, along with ways to fill the graveyard. More on that below.
Explore the top cards from Tarkir: Dragonstorm for Magic: The Gathering Standard. Discover new strategies and meta shifts in this competitive spoiler analysis.
Tarkir: Dragonstorm Cards for Standard So Far
Tarkir: Dragonstorm will be launching on Magic: the Gathering Arena on Tuesday, April 8th, so until we get our hands on the products, jank lovers like myself and, possibly, yourself are stuck speculating on which cards will be good enough to cut it in Standard. So far, with only a few days of preview season under our belts, a few have caught my attention as powerful enough to possibly make the cut. A lot of the current meta, think of as Gruul Mice and Esper Pixie, are very tuned decks and I don't expect these to get many new toys that will be faster or more consistent than their current pieces. That said, I believe (or vainly hope) that a few new archetypes will get the support they need to step up and challenge the current meta in a fun way. Let's look at what those are. Midrange
logo

By joining our community, you can immerse yourself in MTG Arena gameplay. Watch matches, engage with content, comment, share thoughts, and rate videos for an interactive experience.

Follow Us

LATEST VIDEOS