Cruel Reality
Enchantment — Aura Curse
Enchant player
At the beginning of enchanted player's upkeep, that player sacrifices a creature or planeswalker of their choice. If the player can't, they lose 5 life.
Kieran Yanner
Rulings
There are many important moments in the story, but the most crucial—called “story spotlights”—are shown on cards. These cards have the Planeswalker symbol in their text box; this symbol has no effect on gameplay. You can read more about these events in the official Magic fiction at http://www.mtgstory.com.
(wotc • 2018-01-19)
The enchanted player can’t choose to lose 5 life if they have a creature or planeswalker that can be sacrificed.
(wotc • 2017-04-18)
The enchanted player chooses a permanent to sacrifice from among the creatures and planeswalkers that player controls. You don’t choose which type of permanent the player has to sacrifice.
(wotc • 2017-04-18)
Rulings
There are many important moments in the story, but the most crucial—called “story spotlights”—are shown on cards. These cards have the Planeswalker symbol in their text box; this symbol has no effect on gameplay. You can read more about these events in the official Magic fiction at http://www.mtgstory.com.
(wotc • 2018-01-19)
The enchanted player can’t choose to lose 5 life if they have a creature or planeswalker that can be sacrificed.
(wotc • 2017-04-18)
The enchanted player chooses a permanent to sacrifice from among the creatures and planeswalkers that player controls. You don’t choose which type of permanent the player has to sacrifice.
(wotc • 2017-04-18)