Benevolent Offering
Instant
Choose an opponent. You and that player each create three 1/1 white Spirit creature tokens with flying.
Choose an opponent. You gain 2 life for each creature you control and that player gains 2 life for each creature they control.
Ryan Yee
Commander 2014 (C14)
• #3Rulings
You choose the opponents for each effect as the spell resolves.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)
In some unusual cases, the Spirit tokens will have a toughness of 0 or less as they enter the battlefield, perhaps because an opponent controls an enchantment that gives your creatures -1/-1. Because state-based actions aren't performed in the middle of a spell's resolution, you'll gain 2 life for each of those Spirit tokens. After Benevolent Offering has finished resolving, the Spirit tokens will die and subsequently cease to exist.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)
You may choose the same opponent for each of the effects, or you may choose different opponents. None of the affected players are targets of the spell.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)
Rulings
You choose the opponents for each effect as the spell resolves.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)
In some unusual cases, the Spirit tokens will have a toughness of 0 or less as they enter the battlefield, perhaps because an opponent controls an enchantment that gives your creatures -1/-1. Because state-based actions aren't performed in the middle of a spell's resolution, you'll gain 2 life for each of those Spirit tokens. After Benevolent Offering has finished resolving, the Spirit tokens will die and subsequently cease to exist.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)
You may choose the same opponent for each of the effects, or you may choose different opponents. None of the affected players are targets of the spell.
(wotc • 2014-11-07)